I could definitely see Voicethread having potential classroom use, but also having the potential to be blocked by administration.
As an administrator, I would question the content on the website, both visual and audio. We have no control over what other people post, so there is the potential for offensive and/or adult content that students could come across. At the very least, the ability to browse any and all threads could prove too much of a distraction in the classroom. I would be concerned about what the students might hear, as well. Given that this is a sight on which people can respond using a microphone, they are free to say whatever they like, constructive or not. Students could easily come across foul language, racial slurs, inappropriate jokes, etc. while browsing this website. In the end, I would just rather not even offer students the temptation.
I think Voicethread is a great tool for prompting group discussions without having to take up all the classroom time to do it. By having the content available online, students can take their time observing and thinking about said content in order to produce a well thought out response. Since classroom time is limited, not all students get to say everything they wanted to say. Voicethread also lets them make multiple responses to a variety of content. Again, classroom time limits the number of times a student has for speaking and how much can actually be covered. Luckily, the website has the option of a textual response in case the student doesn’t have the technology for a spoken audio response.
After doing some browsing of my own, I came to realize that a lot of school projects have been posted to Voicethread. My students could use this website to look at those same projects, to see what other students have done, and draw from the inspiration. The whole social networking of the website offers students the chance to post their project, go look at one that might be similar, and respond saying, “Hey, I really like your project. You hit some great points. I did a project at my school on a really similar subject. Come check it out!” As Tim Tyson is trying to get teachers to understand, students are much more motivated when they have someone to show their work off too.
As for ways to keep students out of trouble? I think it would be most beneficial if, as a teacher, I browsed the website ahead of time and created a list of appropriate videos for the students to look at. I would only direct them to videos that pertained to what we were doing in the classroom that day. If any students were seen wandering from that designated list, then corrective steps would be taken.
Who Said What